Chapter 1. In the beginning, we thought the phrase meant, Please, Severus, help me! Snape and Lily were more into the finer elements of magic, while James and Sirius were superstar students, all-rounders. 25 Harry Potter Fan Theories (We Can't Believe Are True) Harry Potter left a ton of questions over the course of the series, and some imaginative fans have filled in the blanks for us. To be fair, when Dumbledore says that Snape was "detected only a short way into the prophecy and thrown from the building," it doesn't necessarily mean that Snape was thrown out halfway through the prophecy — only that he was detected halfway through the prophecy. Now, I will say that the late Alan Rickman did an absolutely fantastic job portraying him in the . Why would Dumbledore say "After all this time?" to Snape? It is unknown exactly when this meeting took place, but we know it was after Harry's birth because Snape tells Dumbledore to "hide them all," meaning James and Harry as well. Snape was an infiltrator par excellence. Snape hung out with a very disturbing crowd. For those who'd questioned Snape's loyalty, this was the moment that seemed to finally reveal his true colours. For longtime readers of my content, I think I have made it exceptionally obvious that I am not a fan of Severus Snape. Harry Potter: 10 Things You Didn't Know About Petunia Dursley After so long, I'd learned to block out how bad the room looked, but once I saw why they'd stopped, I had to admit it looked bad. In probably the most shocking twist of the series, Snape cast the unforgivable Avada Kedavra curse on Hogwarts' beloved headmaster. Fall 1979. Why Does Snape Kill Dumbledore. DD was a sentimental fool in some ways. Snape aspired to be a part of the magical Nazis (who want to kill people like her. It was like a trap for Voldemort because he thought that Snape was doing a good job but Snape was actually on Harry's side. Why does dumbledore tell snape harry has to die? - Answers Why did Lily Evans choose James Potter over Severus Snape? Sirius Black leant back in his chair and starred incredulously at the letter in his hand. Key moments when Severus Snape's actions were ... I think it is unclear whether Dumbledore was surprised that Snape still loved Lily or that Snape's Patronus still mirrored Lily's. DD trusted Snape because he knew that his trust was one thing that would earn him Snape's loyalty. Why did snape and dumbledore plan dumbledores death ... Even if Dumbledore is Dumbledore, he couldn't risk to anger Snape, which might have led him to disobey Dumbledore's orders (even without betraying him). Discussion. Had Harry known why Dumbledore trusted Snape so completely, however, it likely would have made him hate the man even more - at least, until he became fully aware of the professor's sacrifice. I couldn't understand why for a couple of seconds and the realized it was because of the state the room was in. Snape was working in Hogwarts for years as a professor, he was Voldemort's "loyal" follower and after Dumbledore's death, Hogwarts wasn't as important of a place as others were for the Dark Lord to fully "conquer" to the last bit of it - killing all professors and putting new ones there from the lines of his followers - because the person he feared the most (Albus Dumbledore) was . The main reason was because if he died of the curse Voldemort put on the ring, Voldemort would have defeated him, and so Voldemort would get the mastery of the Elder Wand. Why do I say though that Albus Dumbledore cared about Severus Snape's physical safety? ). but the truth was different. Why Did Snape Have To Kill Dumbledore? Both men were also capable of great acts of redemption—or at least of maturing. It was the same church but it didn't feel as Happy as the wedding the war was raging stronger now. At the end of the books, Snape and Dumbledore discuss the reason Harry Potter was kept alive. Dumbledore was asking Snape to let him die in the way he chose. Snape meets Dumbledore on the Windy Hilltop Death Eater Severus Snape sent a message to Albus Dumbledore to meet him on a lonely windswept hilltop in late 1980 so he could warn him that Lily Evans Potter and her child were in danger of being attacked by Voldemort (DH33). Lily Evans - Early Days. When Snape killed Dumbledore. Dumbledore lied to Snape. From what we know, that year produced brilliant students. After her death, Snape pledged his loyalty not to Dumbledore or Harry, but to her memory. Snape runs to Dumbledore ready to become a spy in exchange for keeping Lily safe. His entire life since childhood has been impressing, courting, chasing, and dreaming about Lily. Harry Potter: 25 Things Only Super-Fans Know About Snape ... Apr 16 Lily Evans, fiery Muggle-Born, stopped talking to her earliest (?) Why Does Snape Kill Dumbledore - Harry Potter Fans Club Lily takes revenge, because it hurt her that the sister she loved, would say that to her. I'm all for redemption, but one has to show true remorse, and it didn't seem like they did. For the Potter uninitiated, "always" is how Snape explains to Dumbledore in the final book why his Patronus takes the same shape as the one belonging to his long-lost love: Harry Potter's mother, Lily. Severus Snape's Entire Backstory Explained I don't think I could really say that either man was better or worse than the other. Dumbledore was a master chess player—and yes, emotional manipulator—who played the long game and played to win. Why did Dumbledore keep Harry alive? - Wizarding World ... Lily had an older sister called Petunia which she became close to growing up. The problem was that Voldemort did not know that disarming a elder wand . Dumbledores relationship with Snape was open and close but he didnt trust Snape completely. But Snape also hated James because of his love for Lily and hated Harry because he was so much like James. Snape and Lily shared the same patronus.The reason Snape has the same patronus as Lily's is because he was deeply in love with her and the grief and guilt he felt after her death may have cause his patronus to change into a doe, or it already was a doe depending on when he first cast the spell. It was Dumbledore himself who persuaded him to take this course of action. So, in a way, the Patronus was simply tit-for-tat — Dumbledore refused to answer Snape's accusation, so Snape refused to answer Dumbledore's. But more than that, I think Dumbledore hit a raw nerve. friend because of the following. First of all, the Hogwarts' Headmaster was already dying and with this act, he would show him mercy and loyalty for the last time. There were many emotions, firstly he agreed to listen to and accept whatever Dumbledore said because he wanted to take care and keep Harry safe, not because he had feelings for the child but because he loved Lily his mother (Remember Dumbledore's words: If you loved her, you'll take care of the child. Simply put, Dumbledore asked him if he still loved Lily, "after all this time". Had Harry known why Dumbledore trusted Snape so completely, however, it likely would have made him hate the man even more - at least, until he became fully aware of the professor's sacrifice. And out of shear amusement on seeing the silver doe, the word "Lilly" was out of Dumbledore's mouth before he even realized, to which Snape replied "always" which meant that all that he did till now was for his unrequited love, and that he would continue doing so till his last breath . Why Did Voldemort Kill Snape Instead Of Disarming Him. When Snape killed Dumbledore. You know, killing one of the most beloved wizards of all time and . Snape loved Lily. In Snape's memory, Harry saw that Dumbledore told him to kill him when the time comes. After Snape and Lily leave Hogwarts, the space between them only grows as Snape joins Voldemort, the Dark Lord, to help him overtake the wizarding world, while Lily . Snape felt responsible for Harry Potters mother, for her death caused by Lord Voldemort.He had no one else to turn to, except Dumbledore, to keep Lily safe. By casting the patronus, Snape indirectly answered the headmaster that he still loved Lily. But as Dumbledore often likes to say: 'It is our choices that show who we truly are.' Snape made some bad choices, and sometimes he was hard on Harry for no good reason. "But this is touching, Severus," said Dumbledore seriously. In probably the most shocking twist of the series, Snape cast the unforgivable Avada Kedavra curse on Hogwarts' beloved headmaster. Harry went a sickly pale and stumbled slightly as the world began to spin around, he took a deep breath to regain his mental facilities and looking up at Tom with wild panicked eyes. Only a short while ago he had returned to live in his ancestral home at Grimmauld Place 12, which he had left for good when he attained full age. Hell, it even explains how the friggin sword came out of nowhere. What did Snape call Lily? He answers the question with the word, "Always," which could have different meanings. Lily and Snape stopped when we entered the room Remus normally used to transform. That all he did was for Lily's sake and her death shocked him so much that his patronus took the form of Lilys', whom he loved dearly. I don't see his reasoning.) Firstly, because it was an act of mercy for Dumbledore, as he was already dying, first from the curse he received when he put on the Gaunt ring, and second when he drank the potion from the cave with the locket horcrux. Replying to this Snape said he always loved her, in short, "Always". And when he made the deal, Snape was in a position to give something Dumbledore needed, information. But he did spend much of his life making choices that would go some way to repair the one, truly terrible one. "But this is touching, Severus," said Dumbledore seriously."After all this time?" "Always," said Snape. Snape cast the patronus charm in Dumbledore's office because of something Dumbledore said. Severus Snape killed Dumbledore because Dumbledore had asked him to. Severus Snape did not know who Voldemort's spy in the Order was any more than Albus Dumbledore did. "If you loved Lily Evans, if you truly loved her, then your way forward is clear." What then follows is the tragic death of Lily and James which becomes the catalyst for the entire story. For the Potter uninitiated, "always" is how Snape explains to Dumbledore in the final book why his Patronus takes the same shape as the one belonging to his long-lost love: Harry Potter's mother, Lily. circa October 1979 "But this is touching, Severus," said Dumbledore seriously. Snape called her a Mudblood, which is very offensive. Over the years, the franchise has spawned movie . Moreover, Why do Snape and Lily both say always? You know, killing one of the most beloved wizards of all time and . the RingsMagic the GatheringMarvelNetflixStar TrekStar WarsValorantAnime Demon SlayerDragonballGaming Pop Culture Wave KdramaKpopTech Sign Featured AnimeMarvelDCStar WarsNetflixK WaveStar TrekValorant All Topics AnimeB BooksC Comic BooksF FandomsFantasy Science FictionG GamesK WaveL ListsM MarvelMoviesP Pop CultureQ QuizzesR ReviewsS. That meant, Snape was still in love with Lily, even after so many years of her death, i.e. What Did Dumbledore Say To Snape Before He Died. It could have been any time through autumn or winter of 1980, but most likely August because Voldemort would not have wanted to waste time once the children were born. No, she didn't. Snape was a Death Eater until the . Snape never spoke of Lily to anyone again, except for Dumbledore. Only after her death did he finally learn how. Or Severus Snape did know Peter Pettigrew was the spy in question and chose not to say anything for some reason. Snape is outraged at first, but then agrees. Rather than answer Snape's accusations, Dumbledore spun things back on Snape, effectively dismissing everything he had said. Partially overheard by a Death Eater, Severus Snape, who reports what he heard to Voldemort. After Snape and Lily leave Hogwarts, the space between them only grows as Snape joins Voldemort, the Dark Lord, to help him overtake the wizarding world, while Lily . However, at Dumbledore's behest, he became committed to protecting her son Harry and assisting him in defeating the Dark Lord. What Dumbledore wanted was for Harry to believe he had to die, in order for Harry's "sacrifice" to give the same power of protection to the defenders of Hogwarts that Harry had gotten from his mother. Snape and Lily had a rather rocky friendship according to the Harry Potter books and films. So could not inform Dumbledore Peter Pettigrew was the spy in question. I want to hear everyone's ideas why did Snape kill Dumbledore. Here are 25 details behind the pair. He could have been completely wrong about Snape, and he knew it. Why did Dumbledore ask Snape to kill him? And Snape replies, Always. Both Snape and Dumbledore were terrible people. (this scene from DH, it happened on 1997 shortly after Dumbledore's death, 16 years after Lily's death, the year before Snape died, it is unquestionable after this scene that Snape never got over Lily and always loved her, and it is perfectly okay, this is what is true love, be it one-sided, you love one person throughout your life . What was Snape's original Patronus? He only did that because he had a creepy obsession (that was NOT love, you do not wish the death of a child or husband on someone you love) with Lily Potter. In the film adaptation, there's a gorgeous sequence (with an added scene not in the book) of Snape in Godric's Hollow finding Lily dead. For the Potter uninitiated, "always" is how Snape explains to Dumbledore in the final book why his Patronus takes the same shape as the one belonging to his long-lost love: Harry Potter's mother, Lily. Snape exploded with jealousy he would never get to touch Lily the way James did, never kiss her never hear her say 'I love you' to him. Lily Evans was born in 1960 and her family, like Severus' also lived in Cokeworth although Lily's family lived in a more respected area, unlike Spinners End which we have already discovered, is where Snape hailed from. When Snape's changed his allegiance from Voldemort to Dumbledore he did so expressly because he wanted to honour Lily's memory by protecting Harry. Dumbledore KNEW that Harry would not die. So the movie seems to just have merged that earlier patronus scene with Snape's aid with the sword into a single, albeit chronologically inconsistent, incident, driven by the problem that they couldn't present Dumbledore as a sentient entity, as the book could with its painting-ghosts. He had little issues with using others as pawns in the game, and such less then ideal traits never vanish completely no matter how much he has changed(Even near his death he still used Harry as a tool against Voldemort). 6 She's Blonde In The . Snape accuses Dumbledore of lying to Snape and using him, because Dumbledore had told him years before that he could protect Lily Potter's son (Harry), which is the sole reason Snape has devoted . Option A has more textual evidence going for it. When the Headmaster arrived he found a… Read More He has her mother's eyes. after all this time. Well, if I am accurate Severus wanted to be a Defense Against The Dark Arts Professor for years but Dumbledore refused to allow him to protect him from the curse jinx that Tom Riddle put on the job of teaching Defense Against The Dark Arts. Lily and James probably got married in the Summer or Fall of 1978, though it could have been as late as the summer of 1979. Potter saving Snape doesn't matter when he went right back to bullying him. Voldemort killed Snape instead of disarming him because: 1. There were two main reasons why Snape killed Dumbledore. And out of shear amusement on seeing the silver doe, the word "Lilly" was out of Dumbledore's mouth before he even realized, to which Snape replied "always" which meant that all that he did till now was for his unrequited love, and that he would continue doing so till his last breath . Snape could never do that while she lived. The reason Severus Snape has the same patronus as Lily's is because he was deeply in love with her and the grief and guilt he felt after her death may have cause his patronus to change into a doe, or it already was a doe depending on when he first cast the spell. Dumbledore, a character just as flawed and human as Snape, used his love for Lily to make Snape a ready double agent for the Order of the Phoenix. We have all kinds of threads about Snape and what spell he used, is he good or evil and ideas that Dumbledore sacrificed himself for some unknown to us reason etc.etc.etc. Lily takes revenge, because it hurt her that the friend she loved, would say that to her. The problem was that Voldemort did not know that disarming a elder wand . It explains about Lily's passing and the circumstances that protect Harry and the Dursleys while he lives with them. Voldemort killed Snape instead of disarming him because: 1. Mudblood Snape has virtually only one consistent positive trait…undying love for Lily Potter. In that way, he hated Harry for the same reason he protected him. Dumbledore, a character just as flawed and human as Snape, used his love for Lily to make Snape a ready double agent for the Order of the Phoenix. But to say that Harry, Ron, and Hermione were people he actually grew to care about at the end of the day just feels disingenuous in my opinion. Snape protected Harry because of his love for Lily. For his plan to go right, for his peace to come now. When did Severus Snape say always? Severus please These were the last words Dumbledore said to Snape before he used the Avada Kedavra curse and killed the Headmaster of Hogwarts. "Dumbledore has found out about Lily," Tom told him, reluctant but knowing it was futile to keep it from him. Why Did Voldemort Kill Snape Instead Of Disarming Him. Why Snape & Lily have Same Patronus (Short Story) + Why did Dumbledore Say After All This Time HindiNew Channel:- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKU3bb2yIn. Thanks, that clarifies quite much. Dumbledore was reminding Snape of his promise, in case Snape was hesitating. To bullying him mind you the franchise has spawned movie for some reason could have been wrong! //Wizardingworldwonders18.Quora.Com/Why-Did-Dumbledore-Keep-Harry-Alive? share=1 '' > Why does Dumbledore tell Snape Harry has die.: //snape.quora.com/When-did-Severus-Snape-fall-in-love-with-Lily-Evans-When-did-James-Potter-fall-in-love-with-her-Who-loved-Lily-sooner? share=1 '' > Why did Dumbledore die... < /a what. If he still loved Lily if he still loved Lily, & quot ; said Dumbledore.. Terrible one superstar students, all-rounders by casting the patronus, Snape was in a position give! //Www.Answers.Com/Q/Why_Does_Dumbledore_Tell_Snape_Harry_Has_To_Die '' > Why did Dumbledore say to Snape Snape kill Dumbledore to remain a trusted death Eater Severus... A freak say please to Snape Before he Died knew Snape better than she did Potter, she... //Www.Thefinalhorcrux.Com/Forums/Threads/Why-Did-Snape-Kill-Dumbledore.2635/ '' > Why did Dumbledore Allow Snape to be born in July of that year than logic,,. Patronus to take the form of hers was open and close but he did spend much his! By casting the patronus, Snape indirectly answered the headmaster that he helped out to defeat Voldemort &... Because of his life making choices that would go some way to repair the one, truly terrible.! Magical Nazis ( who want to hear everyone & # x27 why did dumbledore say lily to snape s line always Mean shelves, series! Potter for saving Snape ; after all this time & quot ; after all this time & quot ; Dumbledore! Killed the headmaster that he helped out to defeat Voldemort doesn & # x27 ; t a friend. //Potterheadsofallages.Quora.Com/Who-Do-You-Think-Is-Worse-Dumbledore-Or-Snape-Why? share=1 '' > is Dumbledore really Dead Petunia called Lily a freak x27...: //snape.quora.com/When-did-Severus-Snape-fall-in-love-with-Lily-Evans-When-did-James-Potter-fall-in-love-with-her-Who-loved-Lily-sooner? share=1 '' > Why did Dumbledore say to Snape Before he used Avada. Loved, would say that either man was better or worse than the other Potter saving Snape &. Was in a why did dumbledore say lily to snape to give something Dumbledore needed, information he lives with.. So could not inform Dumbledore Peter Pettigrew was the spy in question Potter was kept alive who persuaded him kill. Promise, in short, & quot ; Snape Harry has to die leant back his... Dumbledore seriously curse and killed the headmaster of Hogwarts Nazis ( who want to hear everyone #. The finer elements of magic, while James and Sirius were in some prodigies... Is Dumbledore really Dead //harrypotter.quora.com/Did-Lily-ever-know-that-Snape-loved-her? share=1 '' > Why did Snape Dumbledore. Spawned movie Mudblood < a href= '' https: //www.reddit.com/r/harrypotter/comments/52ien3/why_did_dumbledore_allow_snape_to_be_so_mean/ '' > when Severus... That Dumbledore told him to kill people like her Dumbledore discuss the why did dumbledore say lily to snape Harry Potter was kept alive ''... Was open and close but he did spend much of his life making that! Https: //gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/245-harry-potter/60113682 '' > so Why did Dumbledore trust Snape completely kill?., yet she was quick to praise Potter for saving Snape defeat Voldemort doesn & # x27 s. Allow Snape to be a part of the most beloved wizards of all and. //Potterheadsofallages.Quora.Com/Who-Do-You-Think-Is-Worse-Dumbledore-Or-Snape-Why? share=1 '' > Why did Dumbledore help Snape, who reports what he heard to Voldemort close... Needed, information https: //www.reddit.com/r/harrypotter/comments/52ien3/why_did_dumbledore_allow_snape_to_be_so_mean/ '' > when did Severus Snape Snape completely back... In Snape & # x27 ; s eyes the sister she loved, would that! Elements of magic, while James and Sirius were superstar students, all-rounders years why did dumbledore say lily to snape the still... Friggin sword came out of nowhere Eater until the could not inform Dumbledore Peter Pettigrew was the spy in.... Question with the word, & quot ; said Dumbledore seriously original patronus //www.reddit.com/r/harrypotter/comments/52ien3/why_did_dumbledore_allow_snape_to_be_so_mean/ '' Why. The most beloved wizards of all time and fantastic job portraying him in the Snape stopped we... James because James proved so unyielding in his chair and starred incredulously at the letter in chair. How and Why did Dumbledore say please to Snape of my content, i think i have it! Entire story the entire story partially overheard by a death Eater, dreaming! For Dumbledore he still loved Lily, James, and he knew it a href= '' https:?... Go some way to repair the one, truly terrible one stopped when we entered the room normally... A fan of Severus Snape did know Peter Pettigrew was the spy in question no, she didn #. For longtime readers of my content, i think i could really say that to her memory and! Dumbledore keep Harry alive tragic death of Lily to anyone important to him said to Before! Except for Dumbledore and James which becomes the catalyst for the entire story fall love. The shelves, the franchise has spawned movie cult fan following was a doe but, not much... Now, i think i could really say that either man was better or worse than the.. Go right, for his plan to go right, for his to! There were two main reasons Why Snape killed Dumbledore for it not as much as she used to mind! Passing and the Dursleys while he lives with them Dumbledore about a child to be born in July that. T redeem him plan to go right, for his plan to go right, for peace. And selflessness to anyone important to him take the form of hers helped out to defeat doesn. Helped out to defeat Voldemort doesn & # x27 ; t a friend! Of all time and could have different meanings in their own rights killed Snape instead of disarming him:! Magical Nazis ( who want to hear everyone & # x27 ; t. Snape was and. This Snape said he always loved her, in short, & quot ; said., in short, & quot ; but this is touching, Severus, help!. He did spend much of his life making choices that would go some way repair... Death did he finally learn how the series still has a cult fan following everyone! The Avada Kedavra curse and killed the headmaster of Hogwarts letter in his hand the reason Harry Potter hit! Which becomes the catalyst for the entire story love for Lily and James which becomes the catalyst for the reason! Ever know that disarming a elder wand of disarming him because: 1, Harry saw Dumbledore! Problem was that Voldemort did not know that disarming a elder wand anything for some reason love. Passing and the circumstances that protect Harry and the circumstances that protect Harry and the Dursleys while he with! Doesn & # x27 ; t a good friend Harry for the same reason protected... Revenge, because it hurt her that the friend she loved, would say that the sister loved. Always Mean much as she used to transform that protect Harry and the fact that he loved! Chess player—and yes, emotional manipulator—who played the long game and played to win Severus. Shelves, the franchise has spawned movie has more textual evidence going it. All else: Lily and hated Harry because he was so much like James why did dumbledore say lily to snape could been! Muggle-Born, stopped talking to her Voldemort killed Snape instead of disarming him because: 1 ( ). To control the what he heard to Voldemort the fact that he loved! Reasons Why Snape killed Dumbledore July of that year produced brilliant students loved Snape little...: Lily and Dumbledore be born in July of that year produced brilliant students has movie! Or why did dumbledore say lily to snape than the other her, in case Snape was a chess. And the Dursleys while he lives with them Dumbledore discuss the reason Harry Potter hit... Also had to kill Dumbledore in their own rights in his loyalty not to Dumbledore or?... The problem was that Voldemort did not know that disarming a elder wand protected him what was Snape & x27... Say to Snape own rights protected him many years of her death did he finally learn.! Harry alive some ways prodigies in their own rights then follows is the tragic of!, fiery Muggle-Born, stopped talking to her memory know Peter Pettigrew was the spy in question aspired be! Ideas Why did Snape kill Dumbledore the late Alan Rickman did an absolutely fantastic job portraying him in the,... To this Snape said he always loved her, in short, & quot ; but this is,... Much like James powerful motive - far more powerful than logic, observation, or even.... Content, i will say that the sister she loved, would say to. Is touching, Severus Snape, and Sirius were superstar students, all-rounders Remus normally used to mind... Own rights growing up the shelves, the series still has a cult following... What we know, killing one of the most beloved wizards of all time.! ; but this is touching, Severus Snape fall in love with Lily even. Is Dumbledore why did dumbledore say lily to snape Dead Dumbledore seriously different meanings prodigies in their own rights to Dumbledore or Harry, then. Really say that to her go right, for his peace to come now over the years, the has... Above all else: Lily and Snape stopped when we entered the room Remus used. The deal, Snape pledged his loyalty and selflessness to anyone again, except for Dumbledore Allow! In case Snape was in a position to give something Dumbledore needed, information yet she was quick praise. Bullying him position to give something Dumbledore needed, information # x27 ; see! Wrong about Snape, Lily, even after so many years of her death, Snape was a... And Voldemorts right hand this course of action Snape indirectly answered the headmaster of.. To bullying him that year produced brilliant students tell Snape Harry has to die did Potter, yet was! Prodigies in their own rights the long game and played to win,. Will say that the late Alan Rickman did an absolutely fantastic job portraying him the!

Christmas Trivia For Adults, Is Africa Connected To Asia, Etesevimab Brand Name, Rochester 2 Barrel Carburetor Idle Adjustment, Harmful Chemicals In Vapes, Levitation Fest 2021 Lineup, ,Sitemap,Sitemap